Instructional Services
Home

SEARCHING FOR COLUMBUS

Selected Bibliography of Non-Print and Fiction Resources for K-6

Plus Information for Kids, Parents, and Teachers to Help in Any Search

 

 

PART 2:

MORE INFORMATION FOR PARENTS AND TEACHERS

      Besides listing some very good resources on the topic of Columbus, this bibliography seeks to inform both adults and children about the wonderful databases and homework helps on library websites.  In Part 1, I have tried to write in language that at least 5th or 6th graders can understand on their own.  I leave it up to you to convert the information here into a form that is usable by younger children.  Find the resources for them.  Guide them around the library website.  At the point they begin to surf on their own, share the search techniques mentioned here, and others you have discovered.  Check to see if your library has a research class for their age group.  I firmly believe that the practice of starting at the library website is a technique all children should employ.  It will help them become effective researchers, and ensure that they find information that is appropriate for them. 

     Please note that with most of the items listed as suitable for K-2, I am not suggesting that most children will actually be able to read them.  They will enjoy the rest of the content, and will enjoy the information if you read it to them.  For grades 3-6, the suggested age range does have something to do with average reading abilities. 

      The remaining information in this section for parents and teachers is a repeat of the resources listed in Part 1.  The bits of additional content and review information are meant to supplement what is in Part 1.  Excepting the websites, this list also has more complete bibliographic information to aid you in locating the resources mentioned.  The databases and physical resources items listed in this bibliography were not chosen from the entire universe of available resources, but from those actually available from the two public library systems in the Seattle, Washington area.  (The Seattle Public Library at www.spl.org and the King County Library System at www.kcls.org)  There is, of course, no guarantee that you will find them either in your public library or available for purchase.

 

 

ITEMS OTHER THAN BOOKS IN THE LIBRARY CATALOG

 

For Grades K-2

 

CD-Rom – Jumpstart Explorers – produced by Knowledge Adventure Inc., Fresno, CA (2001) recommended for ages 5-8, ISBN 1581897998 (jewel case), 1581896220 (container).

     I think this game would be improved if the animations representing men were not animal characters, but my young reviewer did not agree.

 

For Grades K-3

 

VHS -Columbus –produced by Spoken Arts – runs 10 minutes (1987), ISBN 080459001X.

     The advantage of this video is that it allows multimedia enrichment of research or curriculum without consuming very much time.  Because illustrations from a book are used, it also provides a bridge to reading.

 

VHS – Christopher Columbus – produced by Castle Vision – runs 45 minutes.

     I think the live acting without voice is an interesting addition to this video.  It helps children visualize real people without having them speak in English, which would of course be inaccurate.  As noted this production moves along well except for the historian segments

 

 For Grades 4-6

 

VHS – Columbus and the Age of Discovery – produced by Films for the Humanities &

Sciences – 7 videos that run 58 minutes each, Princeton, NJ (1991).     This video series could support interesting group projects in the classroom, with each group viewing a different volume, and then presenting the major points to the class.  Varying emphasis of each might make for lively discussions.  Do not make the mistake of thinking the volumes represent some kind of chronological arrangement however.  For example, the last volume is largely focused on modern researchers sailing the course of Columbus’s first voyage. 

 

 

DATABASES ON THE LIBRARY WEBSITE

 

For Grades 2-6

 

The Discovering Collection – produced by the Gale Group –on your library website or learn about it with a PowerPoint demo at http://www.gale.com/ppt_demo/k12-disc.ppt.

     This wonderful database makes a good case for one-stop researching at the library website, especially for young children and those who don’t need very much information.  Even in this one source, various points of view can be found.  Also unlike the Internet, it’s advertisement-free.

 

 

Electric Library Elementary

Encyclopaedia Britannica Online

Grolier Online

Infotrac Kids Edition K-6

 

 

     All of the above databases also can provide many sources in one search.  Electric Library and Infotrac are weighted toward periodicals. Britannica gives a lot of articles with multimedia, plus outside links.  Grolier Online is the encyclopedia and several other components searchable in one step.  Whatever databases your library has, you can be sure they will be information packed.  If you have a favorite that isn’t in the collection, consider lobbying for its purchase.  It will help if you can show that it could replace a less helpful one, assuming there is not a huge difference in cost.

 

BigChalk.com  - at http://www.bigchalk.com/cgi-bin/WebObjects/WOPortal.woa/db/Home.html

     This is a website of the Education Network which sells software and other products for classrooms and media centers.  The advertising is not an aggressive part of the free search feature however.  You can keyword search “Homework Central” from the homepage, and limit it to elementary, middle, or high school if you wish.  On the search page there will be a group of handpicked websites that have been gathered and added to the BigChalk site.  Examples are Worldbook Online and Encarta text articles.  Another group of websites results are ones offsite, but they will open in a window that offers a return to BigChalk.  Last, an unobtrusive link at the top will take adults to applicable free curriculum archives.  It is a wonderful free service, but I do think navigation could be improved at this site.  At the very least, a “back to results” button on every page would help. My preference would be that the subject descriptions, the content clues, and the actual urls be combined on one page. 

 

KidsClick! - at http://sunsite.berkeley.edu/KidsClick!/

     This site was built by librarians and is now maintained at Berkeley.  It has a wonderfully large cleanly designed homepage with links for 15 subject categories plus key sub-categories.  Small icons make it fun, but do not actually help identify the categories.  At the top is a keyword search box that works well, but not perfectly.  Encourage older researchers to try searching by category as well since it will turn up a few more results.  There is a search tutorial and more tools for picture, sound, or advanced searches.

 

KidsSpace at the Internet Public Library - at http://www.ipl.org/div/kidspace/

     On this search page 10 category descriptions are arranged adjacent to a circle in which the picture changes to suggest the topic as you pull the cursor over them.  Additional feature topic suggestions appear at the left.  Examples of these are “U.S. President”, “Science Projects”, and “Story Hour.”  At the top is a keyword search box that can be changed to include the entire IPL, but the search feature is still under construction.  Currently you tend to get a short list of results, and for half of them, the connection to the keyword is obscure at best.  To get a better feel for the potential power of this site, browse any category to see the annotated collections of wonderful websites. Children’s librarians would do well to become familiar with them all.

 

MarcoPolo-Education.org search engine - at

http://www.marcopolosearch.org/mpsearch/basic_search.asp.

     This keyword search box includes possible limits to a certain school subject areas, and the age ranges of K-2, 3-5, 6-8, and 9-12.  Truthfully it is only helpful for children if they remember to change the box at the bottom to exclude lesson plans, because otherwise the results are loaded with them.  If they do remember to do that, they will get good results with a several line description of the content often including the source or website host. You may be familiar with this search page as part of National Geographic Xpedition, but NG is actually only one of the partners of MarcoPolo.org.  The other partners are ArtsEdge, EconEdLink, EdSiteMent, Illuminations, ReadWriteThink, and Science NetLinks. 

 

For Grades 2-6

 

Reference With Encarta  produced by MSN – at  http://encarta.msn.com/encnet/features/reference.aspx.

     This resource has severe limitations since its purpose is to promote purchase of the full resource.  However, if the topic is popular or broad enough to be included, plenty of good information is to be found.

 

Fact Monster – sponsored by the Family Education Network – at http://www.factmonster.com/.

     There are great free resources on the Web, but unfortunately many of them are forced to use advertising to support their continued existence.  Especially if you live in an area with limited subscription database access, it would pay to know about these resources.  KidsSpace is a good place to go to find out about large numbers of them.

 

Worldbook Online, Columbus Article – at http://worldbook.bigchalk.com/125200.htm

     This part of the BigChalk collection is a good reason to use their search engine if you are going beyond library databases.

 

 

SPECIFIC LINKS THROUGH THE LIBRARY WEBSITE

 

For Grades K-6:

 

Columbus Day  - at http://www.jeannepasero.com/columbus1.html.

     Ms. Pasero’s homepage is currently unavailable, so it is difficult to say anything about the source.  However, even if she has no subject expertise, she has done a wonderful job in creating a site full of information, yet simple and colorful enough for the young children to enjoy.  There are tons of pictures and a different tune attached to every page.

 

Looks Are Deceiving: The Portraits of Christopher Columbus  - at http://commfaculty.fullerton.edu/lester/writings/admiral.html.

     This page is a good lesson for older children about the unreliability of portraits before the age of photography.  As the site points out, even the written descriptions of Columbus vary, so it’s hard to know what he really looked like.  The image combining system is fairly useless, but fun.

 

 

For Grades 2-6:

 

Christopher Columbus, His Gastronomic Persona  - at http://www.castellobanfi.com/features/story_contents.html.

     This site may be a winery, but the information is extensive and seems to be well researched.

 

Columbus Mythbusters  - at http://marauder.millersv.edu/~columbus/data/art/LAUFER02.ART

     If you have children read this site or copies of the information there, they will be better informed than many Americans on the subject of Columbus.    

 

The Columbus Navigation Homepage - at http://www1.minn.net/~keithp/index.htm.

      The author of this site is Keith Pickering.  Any site with links to Columbus information is

likely to link to this one, a testament to its fine design, its facts, and its links for further research..

 

For Grades 3-6

 

Biography.com - at http://www.biography.com/search/index.html

     This free PBS site is equivalent to most biography subscription databases, and that is high praise.  Its existence probably accounts for the fact that most of the vendors have to package their biography databases with additional resources in order to sell them.

 

Discoverers Web - at http://www.win.tue.nl/cs/fm/engels/discovery/

     This is an extensive and fairly well organized collection of links to resources on explorers.  I would only wish for a little more annotation.    

 

Internet Medieval Sourcebook -at http://www.fordham.edu/halsall/sbook1z.html.

     The emphasis here is on primary documents, and since Columbus is covered, “medieval” encompasses a larger than normal time period here.  I think the homepage fails as an adequate search tool, which is why, in this case, I linked to an inner contents page.  Many of the included documents are too difficult for most elementary students, but the ones that aren’t provide a wonderful lesson in the strength of examining primary sources.  Any link to this source from age limited searches is definitely worth checking out.

 

Voyages of Exploration: Discovering New Horizons - at

http://www.thinkquest.org/library/lib/site_sum_outside.html?tname=C001692&url=C001692.

     I can’t say enough about the quality of the design and content here, plus any ThinkQuest site is a lesson in what is possible in web design at a young age.  I did not mention it in the kids part, but there are actually quizzes and tracking tools for teachers here as well.  I had included this site in my bibliography before I ran across the site developed by younger children, or I might have given that primary billing.

 

For Grades 4-6

 

The Age of Exploration - at http://www.mariner.org/age/index.html.

     A major purpose of this website is curriculum enrichment.  The activities are actually intended for use by teachers in their classrooms.

 

For Grades 5-6

 

Dr. Thomas C. Tirado’s Document Collection – at http://muweb.millersville.edu/index.html

     Many of the documents here are the old, dull-gray-with-text style, but it is certainly a good place to find obscure information on Columbus.  The Google-enhanced search features make one wish that all sites, especially academic ones, had them as well.

 

1492: An Ongoing Voyage - at http://lcweb.loc.gov/exhibits/1492/intro.html.

     There is lots of good information here.  It’s one of several sites on this list that are the result of efforts to create something special to commemorate the 500 year anniversary of Columbus’s 1492 voyage.

 

 

REASONS TO CHANGE YOUR SEARCH TERMS

 

For Grades 4-6

 

Renaissance - at http://www.learner.org/exhibits/renaissance/

     Results were sparse as I tried to locate sites that would support a study of events leading up to the Age of Discovery.  This site is a wonderful exception to that.  The additional websites linked here may be equally fine, but I have not examined them.

    

For Grades 3-6

 

Deep Look: the Tainos  - at http://www.discoverhaiti.com/history00_1_1.htm.

     As I moved into looking for information about the natives of the Caribbean Islands, I dropped my practice of linking to the homepage, and went straight to the best Taino information.  However, the rest of this site is also fabulous and useful for any number of curriculum angles on Haiti.  There are equivalent sites for the other islands as well.

 

Haiti: Pre-Columbian Hispaniola – Arawak/Taino Native Americans – at http://haiti.uhhp.com/history/precolumbian/tainover.html.

     The overall site is also a great one and goes far beyond the subject of history.  The linked page appears to contain reliable information, but teacher Bob Corbett, who wrote it, admits to drawing conclusions based on the historians he has read rather than attempting to make an exhaustive search including primary documents.  However, he seems to be open to dialogue, even providing links to opposing viewpoints with his article.

 

The Taino Survival – at http://www.lasculturas.com/aa/aa100900a.php.

     This site appealed because it was different with its interview format and provided another side to a controversy.  It opens the door to a discussion about differing opinions, and the thought that assertions unsupported by real evidence may take on the appearance of fact if they are passed unchallenged from generation to generation.

 

The Taino Tribal Organization Website – at http://www.taino-tribe.org/tribal-culture.html/

     I include this site because its creators claim to be descended from the peoples Columbus found when he reached the Caribbean, and because it provides good information about those original peoples.  One of the great parts of multimedia is sound, and the two sites in this entry provide native music.  I am not recommending the second site for anything except the music and picture on its homepage.

 

 

FICTION TO READ

 

 

     With the possible exception of “The Gold of Dreams”, I heartily recommend all the fiction listed here as enjoyable in and of itself, besides offering the opportunity to expand understanding of an important topic.  I also included only that fiction which was very obviously based in fact, and whose embellishment did not affect those facts.  After rejecting “I Discover Columbus” for its farfetched plot unsupported by the facts, and one that made Columbus seem quite the incompetent buffoon, I have to admit that one or two books here give the man rather unbelievably positive characteristics. 

 

 

 For Grades K-2

 

In 1492 - written by Jean Marzollo; pictures by SSteve Bjorkman – 30 pages.  New York: Scholastic (1991).  ISBN 0-590-44413-1

    Beautiful watercolor scenes are peopled with characters that somehow remind me of the animated series “Doug.”  The illustrations both amuse and elicit emotional response to the immenseness of nature.  The book includes prefacing background about Columbus.

 

All Pigs on Deck – written by Laura Fischetto; pictures by Letizia Galli – 30 pages.  New York: Delacorte Press (1991).  ISBN 0-385-30439-0.

     The illustrations are bold outlined layers of color.  Despite the lighthearted text, the sea is wild and filled with large menacing fish while the ship is sailing, so readers connect the voyage with some dangers.  The flat primitively drawn people and their strange postures invite psychological analysis, but I am not sure there is only one conclusion to be drawn.  Includes an endnote about Columbus.

 

For Grades 1-6  (To read or have read aloud)

 

The Boy Who Sailed With Columbus – story and pictures by Michael Foreman - 71 pages. 

New York: Arcade (1992).  ISBN 1-55970-178-1.

    This story, with its short chapters, would make a great read-aloud.   It is the gentle tale of the maturation of one individual lucky enough to have the influences of multiple cultures.  It draws attention to the ethnocentricity of the Europeans without beating the reader over the head with the idea.  

 

Morning Girl – written by Michael Dorris – 74 pages.  New York: Hyperion (1992).  ISBN 0-7868-1358-x (pbk.), 1-56282-284-5 (trade), 1-56282-285-3 (lib. bdg.)

     This award winner captures the rhythms of a nature- and spirit-centered culture.  The thin paperback with six-page chapters will not intimidate the most reluctant reader.  Children will be able to identify with the combination of support and rivalry between the siblings, and perhaps even without knowing anything about what happened to these peoples, react to the menace of the arrival of the Europeans at the end.  The addition of Columbus’s log entry is very effective.

 

He Went With Christopher Columbus – written by Louise Andrews Kent – 318 pages.  Boston: Houghton Mifflin (1940).

      I actually think that today’s children will very much enjoy this book written in 1940.  It pretty accurately chronicles aspects of gentried life in England, religious and port life of Spain, the workings of a ship, the facts of Columbus’s first voyage and his later life, and the effects on the natives as a result of the Spanish colonization.  As such, it is probably a unique fictionalized resource.  It is not perfect.  The side story of the main character is exciting, but to some extent dependent on coincidences.  The narration is usually limited to the action around him, and when it shifts to someone else, I find it a fairly jarring device to further plot and include additional historical detail.  I still would recommend it as a strong addition to the study of this period.

 

For Grades 3-6

 

Encounter – written by Jane Yolen; pictures by David Shannon – 26 pages.  San Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich (1992).  ISBN 0-15-225962-7.

     I actually find the dark message and style of this book disturbing, but it rings true as a possible viewpoint of some of the natives faced with the arrival of Columbus.  There are end notes from the author, and from the illustrator, who has obviously taken great care to include accurate details in his illustrations with the exception, as he explains, of making the Indians completely nude which many might consider unacceptable in a children’s book.

 

For Grades 4-6

 

The Admiral and the Deck Boy – written by Genevieve A. O’Connor – 168 pages.  White Hall, Virginia: Shoe Tree Press (1991).  ISBN 1-55870-218-0.

     Children, especially boys, will identify with Carlos, and the specific sailing terms, many in Spanish, and nautical drawings will enhance it for many.  This is one where the author has probably erred on the side of glorifying the Columbus character, but other than that, the details seem accurate.  It includes a source bibliography as well as the glossaries.

 

The Gold of Dreams – written by Jose Maria Merino; translated by Helen Lane – 217 p.  New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux (1986). 

       I wanted to include an item that gave some information about the spread of religion-based Spanish colonization, without shifting the focus to another explorer or conquistador, or getting heavily into details about non-Taino native culture.  The books by Merino were the only ones I found, and of the two I read, I liked this one better than the other.  I am not a huge fan of the story itself, but I would still recommend it for the way it enhances understanding of the religious Spanish and the clash of cultures.

 

For Mature Readers

 

Freedom Beyond the Sea – written by Waldtraut Lewin; translated by Elizabeth D.

     Crawford – 262 pages.  New York: Delacorte Press ( 2001).  ISBN 0-385-32705-6.

I recommend this book whole-heartedly.  It does portray Columbus as a very perceptive and mesmerizing man, which may be stretching the truth.  However, even that might be excused in this book since it is written in first person, and Columbus is filtered through the eyes of a young girl who is attracted to him.  The details of the burning of Jews and other cruelties are perhaps more graphic than they need be, but they are no doubt accurate to the experience of some, are certainly a big part of the character’s motivation, and since they are memories and in text, I don’t think they are too much for 5th and 6th graders.  The sexual content is mostly restricted to the description of the characters reaction to inadvertent touches, and her confusion about her feelings.  It rings very true to me, but I do admit that the story would have been strong, and in fact, of more general appeal, without taking it into that realm.  With it, I would consider this a “girl’s book.”  I do think that the YA section is the appropriate place for this book, but I don’t think that 6th grade girls in my area of the country, who go to school in the hormone-filled halls of middle school, would be overwhelmed by the content.  It really has to be an individual child-based decision.  As far as I am concerned, any hesitations about violent and sexual content are far outweighed by the positive aspects of this exciting story.  Most of the fiction about Columbus focuses on a male character, so it is refreshing to see a female protagonist.  Real historical details not usually associated with Columbus’s story are included, and some interesting conjectures of historians, also far from general knowledge, are made real as well.  If you don’t think kids should read this book in grades 5 or 6, be sure to recommend it to older girls.

 

     If you are looking for materials on Columbus, I hope you find this bibliography helpful.  I also hope that you utilize the resources mentioned here in a wider context and make it a point to introduce children in your sphere of influence to the wonderful resources of library websites, and the joys of effective researching!

br>
Instructional Services
Home